WheelieDealer Share trading diary blog with Portfolio and Education
  • Home
  • Trades
  • Educational Blogs
  • Wheelie's Bookshop
  • M3 Manifesto
  • Portfolios
  • WheelieBin / WheelieWatchlist
  • Non-Finance Books
  • Beginners
  • Monthly Performance
Picture

educational blogs

Wheelie’s New Improved Index Trading System - Part 1 of 3

28/3/2018

6 Comments

 
Tweet
Anyone who has read some of my Blogs and Tweets and followed what I get up to with my Trades cannot have missed my obsession with trying to Hedge my Long Portfolio of Stocks using Short Spreadbet Positions on Major Indexes. 

This is all about trying to lower Downside Risk - in essence there are 2 types of such Risk - ‘Stock specific’ which can be diversified away by holding a number of Positions and by such things as Sizing to Volatility, diversity of Strategies, diversity of Sectors, diversity of Stock Types (Income, Defensive, Growth, Value, etc.). The other Risk is ‘Market specific’ - this can only be practically reduced or largely mitigated by the use of Index Shorts - which is what this Blog is about.


I have been attempting to Short the Indexes for many Years and overall I have been pretty unsuccessful. My belief in the importance of this comes from some success I did have back in the Credit Crunch where I did well on a lot of Short Positions and as a result it made me realise that there was a lot of sense in keeping my Long Portfolio of Stocks intact rather than selling Stocks before a General Market fall, which was something I had done in the past. It is also a technique which Robbie Burns, the Naked Trader, uses and it is pretty obvious that it can help reduce the pain in terms of Losses when we have a big Market Drop and it also helps with the psychological aspects as I tend to find that having even a Small Short in place diverts my attention to that rather than my worries about the value of my Stock Portfolio tanking !!

It is very much my belief that one of the biggest errors I continually made in the past was to sell great Stocks far too early. This was partly because I was selling Stocks when I thought the Markets in general were going to fall and therefore by Shorting an Index (in practice it is nearly always the case that Major Indexes across the UK, Europe and US are all very closely correlated - so they all move together) it would have the same effect as Selling some Shares and going into Cash. If you sell some Shares in advance of a Market Drop, this has 2 benefits - it means you have less Long Exposure so you suffer less damage and it means you have a Cash Pile ready to buy more Stocks when the Market has bottomed. These same benefits can be gained by Shorting an Index on the way down and then using the Profit generated and some Leverage to go Long on the way back up again - and your Portfolio remains exactly the same.

Shorting this way has other advantages as well - it means your Portfolio is unchanged so you are still exposed to any Ex-Dividend Dates and this keeps the Dividends flowing in and, more importantly, it is far cheaper - if you sell several different Stocks before a Market Drop, then you could run up a lot of Dealing Costs and you will also get a load more Costs when you buy back in at the bottom. By just using one or two Index Shorts and one or two Index Longs on the bounce, you are incurring much less Cost. It is also practically very easy to undertake and just like ‘Flicking a Switch’.

The other problem with selling Stocks before a Drop is that you are unlikely to be able to get your Cash back into the Markets fast enough to be able to maximise the Gains off the bottom when the Markets bounce - the speed in terms of turning Hedging On and Off is a huge benefit. I guess this applies in the Selling stage as well - it takes time to trim your Stock holdings.

I had been trying to Short various Indexes for quite some time and with varying success but things really went badly wrong in 2016 when I timed my Shorting well but when things reversed I got caught with a very big Position which was pretty much counter balanced by the Long Portfolio and was, if you like, a ‘Perfect’ Hedge - but the trouble was that it was too perfect and I struggled to get the Short closed when clearly I needed to do this and I made the amateur error of letting the problem run (this was partly because I knew I was making Money on my Longs so the overall effect was fairly neutral) but to cut a long and painful story short, the end result was that by the Close of 2016 I had not made any Money because my Longs and Shorts had balanced each other out but the problem was that I had missed out on probably 6 or 7% of Gains - this was very expensive. If you go back through my Blog Archive of 2016 there is a lot about this as it happened and if you look at the ‘Scores on the Doors’ Blog for 2016 that will tell you more about the end result (I have included this Blog in the ‘Related Blogs‘ section at the bottom of this particular Blog).

After this disaster clearly something had to be done about it - there is no way I could accept a repeat of this and of course the easy thing to do would be to just give up and forget about trying to Hedge my Portfolio. However, that just seems a total cop out and there was no way I was going to do that until I had thought about what I was doing and figured out whether or not I could fix the problems. It struck me that the issue was not to do with my Market Timing - at a guess I would say that this is pretty good and I am probably right for a very high percentage of the time - it could be as high as 70% plus. So the problem had a lot more to do with how I was Executing my Trades and in particular there was clearly an issue with Discipline (or lack of it !!!). I will expand on these problems in a separate Section further down this Blog and also on the steps I have taken to address these.

So far I have really focused on the Hedging aspects from going Short on an Index but my ‘New Improved Index Trading System’ also works for Long Trades - and this is in effect a counterpart and addition to Short Trades because when we get a big Drop in the Indexes, it is very possible that you can close the Short Trade(s) and bank a Profit and then switch to a Long Trade on the same or other Index and make some more Profit on the powerful Bounce-back as the Markets come up off the bottom. Of course it is impossible to pick the exact and precise Bottom but you don’t need to - you can be quite ‘late’ in terms of getting a Trade on but it doesn’t matter, there is still a lot of Profit to be made very quickly. This is an important concept and applies to when you go Short just off the Top as well - you can never get the exact Top but there is no point worrying about it and you can do very well by going Short not far after the Top and letting your Trade run.

In fact, this is a key element of how my System ‘works’ - it is the Classic Trading Model whereby you execute many Trades over a period of time and it is the aggregate Gains/Losses of these Trades that make the System effective or not. The key is to have plenty of Losing Trades but to ensure that when they happen the Losses ‘banked’ are small whereas you also have loads of Winning Trades and when you win, you win big. Again, dropping back to ‘Classic’ Trading Theory, you could have 65% Losing Trades but if you make sure you only have small and controlled Losses, then overall your System will make Money. It is vital to understand this and to embrace cutting a Position when (or before) it hits your Stoploss and to see this as just part of executing the System - this is the key to ‘Discipline’.

Think about it like this. If you just had a 50/50 Win/Lose rate (and let’s face it, the Proverbial Monkey with a Pin can probably achieve such a rate), then if your Losses are cut very early but your Winners are allowed to run to big Profits, then overall you will make good money.

The Principles of how my Trading System works will really apply to any Traded Asset and in particular the same ideas should work really well on very liquid Stocks and certainly I would think FTSE350 Stocks would be ideal. However, with individual Stocks there are some specific Risks like the possibility of a Takeover if you are Short on a Stock which can be a killer and sudden Bad News like a Profit Warning can whack you hard if you are Long on a Stock. Part of the attraction of Trading Indexes is that you don’t have these kinds of problems and they have very low Deposit/Margin Requirements when using Leverage via Spreadbets and/or CFDs. You can also use ETFs (Exchange Traded Funds) to do such Index Trading (these are in effect Funds which you can buy and sell just like normal Shares).

I have not had much (if any) experience of using such a System for Stocks but it strikes me that a Stock with a high Price (for example AstraZeneca AZN at around 4788p) would be advantageous compared to a Stock with a lower Price like KCOM at 89p - this is simply because a given % move in AZN would provide more ‘Points’ for a Speadbet than for KCOM. For example, a 5% move in AZN is 239 points but on KCOM a 5% move is just 4.5 points (with Spreadbets you ‘bet’ a certain number of Pounds per Point - so the more Points the more Pounds can be made or lost).

Spreadbets also have a lovely advantage when trading Foreign Assets like for example US Stocks or US Indexes (which would be listed in $s) because you can bet ‘£s per Point’ so even though they are priced in $s you in effect carry no Forex Risk. Spreadbets are Tax Free also which is super sweet.

Problems apparent in my ‘Old’ Trading System
I have put a lot of thought into why I was failing with how I was doing things and the following Problems are where I put the blame:
  • I was lacking Discipline when it came to Stoplosses - this was two-fold - Firstly I would often ignore the Stoploss and end up running my Losses and having to Close the Position with a much bigger Loss than I should have had, and secondly my Stoplosses tended to be too wide and these meant that even if I was disciplined, I still took a big Loss.
  • My Position Sizes were far too large - I guess this could be seen as ‘Greed’ and I have learnt that reining in my Exposure has been hugely beneficial. The problem I found with huge Positions was that when a Trade moved against me and got near the Stoploss, I would be making big Losses that I had to then ‘lock-in’ by Closing the Positions - this put a lot of pressure on me psychologically and I often chickened out and let the Trade run past the Stoploss in the forlorn hope that it would reverse and go my way - and this just meant that I ended up losing even more. With smaller Position Sizes I can have Stoplosses where the Loss is perfectly acceptable and I am having no such problems with Discipline now I am using far smaller Positions. To add some colour here, I have pretty much just finished reading Robbie Burn’s latest Book ‘Trade like a Shark’ and I noticed that when he talks about doing Index Shorts, he actually says keep the Position Sizes sensible and don’t get greedy.
  • Trading Techniques like ‘Scaling-in’ and ‘Scaling-out’ are a key part of my New Improved Trading System and they are worth taking full advantage of - this is particularly important when Entering the Trades and I am much better at this now. This also means that if a Stoploss gets hit the Loss is smaller because the Initial Position Size is relatively smaller.

Solutions to the Problems I had with the Old System
When outlining the Problems above I touched on the Solutions but this Section covers them in more depth:
  • Position Sizing - I am now using a Starting Position when I open an Index Trade which is worth around 10 to 15% of my Long Portfolio Value. The way I am determining this is to use my Charts to firstly identify where the Trade is likely to be Opened and then to decide where my Stoploss should be placed. Once I have worked this out, I know how many Points I am going to lose if the Trade goes against me and I can then work back from the amount of Money I am prepared to lose. For example, if I am prepared to lose say £500 on a Trade, then if the particular Trade I am calculating would mean a Loss of 60 Points if the Stoploss gets triggered (the distance from the Opening Level to where my Stoploss will be placed), then I would bet about £8 a Point because this is a round number when you divide £500 by 60 Points (60 x £8 is £480). So my Position Size is determined by the Potential Loss on the Trade and the Amount of Money I am prepared to Lose if the Stoploss is triggered. Doing it this way makes the Position Sizing a lot easier and more scientific in fact - I used to agonise about how large my Positions should be and now that is largely out of my hands. In terms of Portfolio Value, at the moment I tend to go for a Stoploss that is equivalent to about 0.2%-0.3% of my Total Portfolio Value (however, that might change in the future).
  • Scaling-in - After doing the stuff I mentioned in the Position Sizing bit above, I place the Trade with my Spreadbet Broker (I use igIndex and they are superb) and then it becomes a case of Monitoring it. I tend to work on Full Day Candlesticks and Technical Analysis information that is generated at the End of Day (EOD) - working in this way keeps things ‘cleaner’ and less Noisy and also means that I am looking at my Charts in the evening when the Markets are shut and moves that are taking place in real-time on the Markets are not affecting my Emotions and leading me to inaccurate conclusions - I find this a huge help. So every Night I am monitoring the Trade and if it starts to go my way and it gives further Buy Signals, then I will think about adding to the Trade which can often mean doubling up on the Position Size. However, again I need to think about the Stoploss and size the Extra Position accordingly - sometimes this means moving the Stoploss on the Existing Position as well but I am fairly flexible on this aspect. If I do not get a further clear Buy Signal, then I will not add to the Existing Trade. Quite often I will double my Existing Position with an Additional Trade but of course this is largely determined by where the Stoploss is going to be.
  • Very tight Stoplosses - with my usual Investing activities I have a strong dislike of Stoplosses and I see them as a hindrance rather than a help. It is also mystifying to me why People use such wide Stoplosses - I see many people using perhaps 15% or 20% Stoplosses on Stocks and this seems daft - if a Stock has fallen 15% you should be thinking about Buying it not Selling it !! So when it comes to my Index Trades, I want to be out very fast if the Trade is going wrong. This tends to work really well if I combine an extremely good Entry with a Tight Stoploss - for example, let’s say I want to Short an Index just after an Inverted Hammer Candle when the Index has had a strong and sustained run up, then such a Candle is a very good Reversal Signal and I would go Short with a Stoploss which is placed just above the Top or ‘Wick’ or ‘Tail’ of the Inverted Hammer Candle and this means I am Entering the Trade with a high likelihood of being right but if it goes against me, then I am out fast and I can reassess the situation and look to Short in perhaps a day or twos time. Note that Robbie ‘Naked Trader’ Burns is a big fan of Stoplosses but in recent years he has started using much tighter Stoplosses and getting out early. Having said all that, I think Tight Stoplosses can only really work well if you have pretty good timing on your Entry into Trades and the Candlesticks and things like Breakouts can really help with such Entries. Of course you don’t always have to let the Trade go against you to the Stoploss - you can close it earlier if you think it is not going to work. In a later Part of this Blog Series I will look at 4 particular Trade Set-ups where I like to put on Long and Short Index Trades with a high expectation of them working as well as the ability to use pretty tight Stoplosses.
  • Trailing Stoploss - if a Trade or pair of Trades go my way, then I can move the Stoploss up behind it to make sure that I at least lock some Profit in if things turn quickly. However, in practice I tend to find that I Close my Positions before they hit a Trailing Stoploss because I am very focused on a Trade once it is running and they usually seem to run for only a few days.
  • End of Day (EOD) Close Stoplosses with a Manual Trigger - because I work off Daily Candlesticks to a large extent, and also because I don’t want my Trades to get ‘Spiked out’ (this is when you have a firm Stoploss Order with your Spreadbet broker and then during the Day there is a ‘Spike’ and your Trade gets Closed out, only for the Price to move back to where it was and by the Day’s Close, it is still away from your Stoploss Level), I do my Stoplosses on an ‘End of Day’ Close basis and I trigger them myself if they get hit. This avoids Spikes intraday but it means that I need to be extremely well disciplined and I have to except that sometimes there is a bit of ‘Slippage’ (this is where the Price hits my Stoploss Level but by the time I get to Close it, the Price has carried on moving and done more damage) - in practice I find this tends not to be too much of a problem. Perhaps I am worrying about nothing and I should use firm Stoplosses with my Broker - I might try it sometime.
  • Use Daily Funded Bets (DFBs) - I have used the Quarterly Funded Bets a few times but because these include the Daily Interest Charges for the remaining Days/Weeks in the Contract, if you Close the Position after just a few Days then you have paid for lots of Interest that you did not need. In practice I find my Index Trades are only on for maybe 10 Days at the most so using the DFBs is probably the best idea (on these you pay a Daily Interest Charge for every Day that you have the Bet open - they are pretty good value really).

OK, that’s it for Part 1. In the next Part I talk about those 4 particular Trade Setups that I really like and my intention for Part 3 is to produce some Examples with real Chart Pictures in them to demonstrate the actual Trades - I have not started this yet so it might turn out to be a right Dog’s Brekkie !!

If you look at my ‘Trades’ page then you should be able to see loads of examples where I have been doing these Index Trades - it was really at the tail end of 2017 where I finally got this Approach settled in the WheelieBrain and I have been following it since then. Every Weekend, usually very late on a Sunday Night, I produce a ‘Charts Blog’ and I tend to talk a lot about Index Technical Analysis in these and there are loads of Charts and I usually show any Index Trades I have running on those Charts.

Cheers, WD.


Related Blogs:
Here is that Scores on the Doors one which shows exactly how not to do it !! (it is really in the Section on ‘Spreadbetting Account’ where the gory details are laid out):

http://wheeliedealer.weebly.com/blog/scores-on-the-doors-2016
6 Comments
Damo
28/3/2018 08:26:55 pm

Thanks Pete , looking forward to the next bit now. 0.2% is where I'm currently trialling my risk , I use Jasons ? free risk sheet to help me , useful tool. Stuck on how to move my stop up if I add to a trade at the mo ' , multi R trade? Will you be covering that in future parts?
Thanks again , very useful topic especially currently for me. Just trying to make a few quid while the longer term stuff is going sideways.
Cheers
Damo.

Reply
WheelieDealer
31/3/2018 11:24:07 pm

Hi Damo, I am typing this on Saturday Night 31st March and last night I pretty much finished Part 2 but it needs a Proof Read and there are some bits I want to tweak having thought about them today. In theory Part 2 will come out mid week and that will be pretty much all the words done but Part 3 will have the 'Examples' in it which will be more chart-based (if I can really decide how to do them !!). I remember Jase (@stealthsurf) talking about his Risk Sheet and I understand people can get it for free from his Website www.tradingbases.co.uk. In Part 2 I have put a section on 'Trailing Stoplosses' and I am thinking that in the Examples one I can include a bit on this.
Great to hear it is a timely topic - looks like you and I are following the same logic of trying to pinch some Cash out of the Markets using such Index Trades etc while our Stock Portfolios are finding it hard to make headway.
Cheers, Pete

Reply
Jase @stealthsurf
29/3/2018 09:13:48 am

Thoughts on the AZM & KCOM comparison. The problem with trading a set £ per point is with high price stocks you would make many points but the weighting on the trade (gap risk) could be huge compared with the KCOM weighting. In effect you could have 5% in KCOM and 35% in AZM if you use a set £ per point. This is why you need to do the position size calculation first. Basically you divide your risk % of portfolio by the area distance (in points) where you are wrong. This will basically end with you always having more £ per point weighting in cheap stocks and less £ per point in large caps. A bit off topic but this is how its done

Reply
WheelieDealer
31/3/2018 11:31:10 pm

Hi Jase, great to see you reading this Blog as I guess it is in some ways closer to what you tend to do with your 'System'. I am in full agreement with you on your comments - I didn't really explain that bit particularly well and I guess the point I was trying to make was that something that doesn't move much and only gives a few Points for a % move would probably be quite choppy and something more liquid would be better to use (for example, you get much clearer Candle Patterns with something that is very liquid) - that is a beauty of the Indexes in that they are very liquid. You are spot on with the 'Pounds per Point' - it is essential to vary them depending on the amount of Money you are prepared to Risk if your Stoploss gets hit - I think between the two of us Readers should be able to make sense of it. As always it is vital with Spreadbets to understand 'Exposure' and 'Risk'.
Cheers, Pete

Reply
Paul Hunt
29/3/2018 11:12:51 am

Hi WD,

messed up on my only stock short which was royal mail who i worked for. i could only see problems for the company but the share price went up and up and took me for about 2% of my PF.

I have often thought of shorting the Dow on a friday last thing with a 100 point stop loss. Markets seem to move quite a bit on a monday especially if bad news come in over the weekend. Must check up and see if that works.

I am not sure about shorting the market just to cover your shares as: 1 your shares may or may not go down. 2 You lose a lot of the gain if the market goes up. Just my thoughts. No right or wrong way about it

Great thought provoking article as ever

Paul

Reply
WheelieDealer
31/3/2018 11:39:00 pm

Hi Paul, great to hear the Blog got you thinking - hopefully once I have issued Part 2 and Part 3 it should really get your Brain firing with neurons !!
I probably mentioned in the Blog that I rarely Short Stocks and if I did it would most likely be driven more by the Technical Picture than by any particular Fundamental view of the Company - in other words it is best to Short something that is already in a Major Downtrend.
There is a theory that 'Monday reverses Friday' and anecdotally it does seem to be true quite often but of course if you actually Backtest it that might not actually hold true.
In terms of Shorting to cover my Long Shares, it doesn't matter if the Shares don't fall - in fact, if my Portfolio holds up but the Index falls then I am 'winning' both ways !! Using a Tight Stoploss on the Index Short means that I am stopped out very fast if the Market continues to rise so the Cost is not too bad (especially as I tend to build the Trade in 2 stages - so the Initial Position is relatively small and when Stopped out it would be a pretty limited hit - 0.3% of Portfolio at the most).
Thanks for the comments, Pete

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    'Educational' WheelieBlogs

    Welcome to my Educational Blog Page - I have another 'Stocks & Markets' Blog Page which you can access via a Button on the top of the Homepage.

    I hope you find the Entries here thought provoking and valuable. There is a sizeable Archive starting to build - use the Filters below to take the full benefit. If you have just Landed on this Page, feel free to have a poke around at the rest of my Website (s)....WD

    Blog Index List  now sits on the WD2 Website - click the Button below:


    BLOG INDEX LIST

    Archives

    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014

    Categories

    All
    Accounting
    Beginners
    Bonds
    Book Reviews
    Business Information
    Commodities
    Conference Reports
    Danger
    Events
    FOREX
    Fundamental Analysis
    Funds
    Getting Started With Stocks
    Guest Blogs
    Hedging
    Income Portfolios
    Information Sources
    Interviews
    Investment Strategy
    IPO
    Macroeconomics
    Manifesto For Making Money
    Market History
    Market Structure
    Non-Finance Books
    Peer 2 Peer Lending
    Politics
    Portfolio Management
    Psychology
    Retirement/Freedom
    Scores On The Doors
    Selling Rationale
    Short Term Trading
    Social Media
    Spreadbetting
    Stock Buy Rationale
    Stock Ideas
    Technical Analysis
    Templates
    Tools And Techniques
    Trades
    Trading Products
    WD Messages
    Week Ahead Indexes


    Please see the Full Range of Book Ideas in Wheelie's Bookshop.

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Trades
  • Educational Blogs
  • Wheelie's Bookshop
  • M3 Manifesto
  • Portfolios
  • WheelieBin / WheelieWatchlist
  • Non-Finance Books
  • Beginners
  • Monthly Performance